Honorary judgeship at the tax court
The participation of honorary judges in the administration of justice is an essential element of German jurisdiction. It is of great importance as a practical implementation of the principle of democracy. Volunteer judges should contribute the experience, knowledge and values they have gained in their daily, professional and social environment to the hearings and joint deliberations and thus usefully complement the more legalistic viewpoint of the professional judges.
In the fiscal courts, the senates of the fiscal courts regularly decide with three professional judges and two honorary judges. The honorary judges do not participate in decisions made outside of the oral hearing or in court decisions. The same applies if the Senate makes use of its power to assign the legal dispute to one of its members as a single judge for a decision in simple cases of no fundamental importance by means of a decision in the preparatory proceedings. In addition, the parties involved can agree to a decision by the chairperson or the appointed rapporteur. In this case, the honorary judges and the other professional judges of the senate no longer participate in the proceedings if the chairperson or the appointed rapporteur makes use of the declaration of consent of the parties involved. There are also no honorary judges at the Federal Fiscal Court in Munich.
Like professional judges, honorary judges are only subject to the law. They are not subject to any orders or instructions when determining the law and are obliged to remain absolutely neutral. They have the same rights and the same responsibility as professional judges in the oral hearing and in reaching a verdict.
Who should I contact?
The honorary judges are elected from lists of nominees drawn up by the President of the Fiscal Court every five years.
Requirements
Honorary judges must be German. They must be over 25 years of age and have their place of residence or place of business within the court district.
What are the fees?
Honorary judges receive an expense allowance as well as reimbursement of travel expenses and loss of earnings for the exercise of their honorary office.
Process flow
The President of the Tax Court draws up a list of proposed honorary judges every five years. The honorary judges are elected by a committee appointed by each fiscal court.
The President of the Fiscal Court determines the required number of honorary judges in such a way that each is expected to be called upon to attend a maximum of twelve ordinary sitting days per year. No special expertise or prior knowledge is required.
Notes (special features)
Honorary judges are generally obliged to accept the office.
Appointment to this office can only be refused in exceptional cases. They are authorized to do so:
Clergymen and ministers of religion
Aldermen and other honorary judges
Persons who have served two terms as honorary judges at the tax court
Persons who have reached the age of 65
Doctors, nurses, midwives and pharmacy managers who do not employ a pharmacist
NOTE: In cases of particular hardship (e.g. infirmity, predominantly working abroad or needing to care for underage children), an application can be made to be exempted from taking up office. The decision is made by the responsible senate of the tax court.
Honorary judges receive compensation for their work in accordance with the Judicial Remuneration and Compensation Act (JVG).
-Compensation Act (JVEG). This includes
Reimbursement of travel expenses,
Compensation for expenses,
compensation for other expenses,
compensation for lost time,
compensation for disadvantages in housekeeping and
compensation for loss of earnings.
What else should I know?
Honorary judges are generally obliged to accept the office.
Appointment to this office can only be refused in exceptional cases. The following are entitled to do so:
Clergymen and ministers of religion
Aldermen and other honorary judges
Persons who have served two terms as honorary judges at the tax court
Persons who have reached the age of 65
Doctors, nurses, midwives and pharmacy managers who do not employ a pharmacist
NOTE: In cases of particular hardship (e.g. infirmity, predominantly working abroad or needing to care for underage children), an application can be made to be exempted from taking up office. The decision is made by the responsible senate of the tax court.
Honorary judges receive compensation for their work in accordance with the German Judicial Remuneration and Compensation Act (JVEG). This includes
Reimbursement of travel expenses,
Compensation for expenses,
compensation for other expenses,
compensation for lost time,
compensation for disadvantages in housekeeping and
compensation for loss of earnings.